Dodgers: 3 players who could be left off playoff roster

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA - JUNE 01: Dave Roberts #30 of the Los Angeles Dodgers in the dugout during a 3-2 loss to the St. Louis Cardinals at Dodger Stadium on June 01, 2021 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Harry How/Getty Images)
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA - JUNE 01: Dave Roberts #30 of the Los Angeles Dodgers in the dugout during a 3-2 loss to the St. Louis Cardinals at Dodger Stadium on June 01, 2021 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Harry How/Getty Images)
3 of 3
Next
Pitcher Evan Phillips #59 of the Los Angeles Dodgers (Photo by Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images)
Pitcher Evan Phillips #59 of the Los Angeles Dodgers (Photo by Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images) /

It’s nothing personal for the Los Angeles Dodgers, at this point. It’s strictly title-defense business.

And, considering this team could be stuck in a one-game Wild Card scenario, the margin for error is thin as an eyelash. No excuses. No mistakes. No more Mr. Nice Guy in divvying up roster spots.

Considering LA’s opening playoff round might be only nine innings long (hence the reason Justin Turner and Co. didn’t really celebrate much when the team clinched), Dave Roberts and the front office have the luxury of leaving a few pitchers off their 26-man roster. For example, if Walker Buehler relieves Max Scherzer, something has gone horribly wrong.

The ability to ditch a starter or two gives the Dodgers the ability to fold an extra reliever onto the roster, but for the purposes of this exercise, we’re not going to take the cop out and just say, “Clayton Kershaw probably won’t be on the Wild Card Game roster. OK, goodbye!” As far as we can tell, these names should be wary about their postseason futures this October, because their slots are far from secure as Los Angeles (hopefully) advances.

Currently, the Dodgers are sitting at a maximized version of their roster, bringing 28 active players to any given game down the stretch. When Oct. 6 arrives, that’ll be forcibly trimmed down to 26.

As we see it, the bench looks fairly secure … well, except for one name. We’ll get into that in a second. Surely, entering this all-important contest, LA will be thinking pitching, first and foremost. What if disaster strikes? Remember Luis Severino in the 2017 Wild Card Game? In the blink of an eye, the Yankees had to pivot and cover 8.2 innings with bullpen arms. The more, the merrier — especially people who can give you length.

With everything hanging in the balance, it’s certainly difficult to figure out who could be on the outside looking in, especially as LA has established a rhythm with this exact roster down the stretch. As far as we can tell, these three players should be on edge, though.

These 3 Dodgers haven’t secured a playoff roster spot yet.

3. Evan Phillips

Yes, the Dodgers need bullpen arms. We’ve established this. And maybe, just maybe, they opt to keep Evan Phillips over, say, Buehler, who’s absolutely, positively not going to make an appearance on Oct. 6.

But, then again, has the rarely-used Phillips really done anything much to justify his inclusion for a do-or-die game?

The righty was activated off the IL on Aug. 30 when Mitch White went down — remember him? — and has only pitched sparingly since being imported as a desperation waiver claim, back in the day when arms like Edwin Uceta were ping-ponging back and forth to the surface.

Don’t believe us? Check the usage chart. Since making his Dodgers debut on Aug. 19 against the New York Mets with 2.1 three-hit innings of one-run relief, he’s only appeared four times in September, and allowed a pair of earned runs in an inning of relief in LA’s catastrophic loss to the D-Backs earlier this week.

Phillips isn’t finishing strong, nor is he stating his case very often at all. Odds are, he’s the first name jettisoned from the staff when the Dodgers have to make some tough postseason decisions — and, speaking of, has there been any talk of bringing White back from Triple-A? That might be another roster spot claimed by an unexpected arm, now that you mention it. There simply won’t be room for Phillips.

Andrew Vasquez #68 (Photo by Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images)
Andrew Vasquez #68 (Photo by Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images) /

2. Andrew Vasquez

Somehow, the Dodgers managed to finagle their Aug. 31/Sept. 1 trade for Twins lefty Andrew Vasquez under the deadline, allowing the pitcher to be postseason eligible, if things came down to it. We’re not sure how it happened, either.

What’s even stranger? Vasquez got a fairly extensive early showcase immediately after joining the Dodgers. He was thrust into the fire twice against their most heated rival, the massively disruptive San Francisco Giants, and emerged with flying colors twice.

Vasquez pitched to three batters in the bottom of the 10th inning on Sept. 3, with LA briefly leading 2-1. That was his Dodgers debut. Brandon Crawford singled to score the unearned garbage run that Rob Manfred gave the Giants for free, but then he retired Thairo Estrada and whiffed Mike Yastrzemski with the winning run on third.

Evan Phillips fared far worse, losing the game the very next inning. Also, Shane Greene pitched a bunch in that game. Shane Greene! Ha! Remember him?

His next appearance came in a series-ending loss in San Francisco two days later; the lefty threw a perfect eighth inning, striking out two.

And now, in the three weeks since then, we haven’t heard a peep from him. Not a peep! Not a squeak. Not a scream. Nothing.

It seems fairly clear the Dodgers won’t be considering Vasquez for their playoff roster, which is odd, considering he already succeeded in two pseudo-playoff games on the road against the team they’re chasing.

Matt Beaty #45 of the Los Angeles Dodgers (Photo by Michael Owens/Getty Images)
Matt Beaty #45 of the Los Angeles Dodgers (Photo by Michael Owens/Getty Images) /

1. Matt Beaty

OK, it’ll probably be two pitchers knocked off the roster. Probably. You’d think.

But (Bill Simmons voice) … are we sure Matt Beaty’s making the one-game Wild Card Game roster now that Gavin Lux is getting reps in the outfield?

Think about it. Again, it’s far more likely that Los Angeles will prioritize pitching; they need to stack the roster with as many live arms as possible, in case disaster strikes. On the other side of the ball … you want to win or lose these games with your best players. Bar none. Holding onto a fifth outfielder? You can talk yourself out of it.

In a one-game scenario, Trea Turner, Justin Turner, Max Muncy and Corey Seager will start. Albert Pujols and Lux will be ready off the bench, as well as Austin Barnes. As long as Mookie Betts, AJ Pollock and Chris Taylor can stay healthy another week, that’s your trio.

The Dodgers could opt for a four-man bench, sure. But Beaty doesn’t provide much in the way of speed. He’s only made one start in September. He also — and I feel bad even typing this — doesn’t have a single pinch-hit this month. Beaty has a single plate appearance in each game listed here: Sept. 11, Sept. 12, Sept. 13 (hit by pitch), Sept. 14, Sept. 15 (somehow hit by pitch again!), Sept. 19, Sept. 21, Sept. 23, Sept. 24, Sept. 25. Not a hit in the bunch.

We’re not forcibly ejecting Beaty from the roster ourselves. We’re just left wondering if Los Angeles would carry an extra bench bat who’s not producing.

Next