Though it wasn’t quite an “Old Man Yells at Cloud” moment, that’s how St. Louis Cardinals fans interpreted recent comments out of Los Angeles Dodgers third baseman Justin Turner’s mouth.
Dodgers fans can thank Barstool for the bad publicity, because Turner appeared on the “Starting 9” podcast with former MLBer Jake Arrieta and “Barstool Carl” (cool?) to talk baseball topics, and may have gotten himself wrapped up in a topic he wish he could take back.
It’s hard to blame JT for getting frustrated about what’s magnified on social media, but he expressed a particular distaste for fans getting all pumped about Cardinals top prospect Masyn Winn rifling a ball 100 MPH from shortstop to first base.
The 20-year-old, who dominated High-A before getting the bump to Double-A a few months ago, has logged 99 games at shortstop across his 106 games this year and appears to be on the proper trajectory to make a big-league impact in a couple years.
But to JT, achieving that success isn’t all about starring in a viral clip where you unnecessarily hurled a ball across the diamond to throw a runner out by five steps. Turner seemingly meant no harm by his comments, but Cardinals fans didn’t take it that way, especially since he was taking the time to put Winn, a 20-year-old kid, on blast in a major forum.
Justin Turner doesn’t give a shit if you can throw the ball 100mph across the diamond.. pic.twitter.com/b6e0YpknhE
— Starting 9 (@Starting9) August 29, 2022
Dodgers’ Justin Turner ripping Masyn Winn has resulted in backlash
Unfortunately, Turner opened up a can of worms that won’t be shut until the Dodgers send the Cardinals packing again when the playoffs roll around.
Cards Twitter went in on the slugger over the last couple days.
Masyn Winn has 3 errors in 70 games at AA. Justin Turner has 5 Errors in 53 games this year. Perhaps he should try throwing harder. https://t.co/mo0VZC4Hy6
— Tieran (@Tieran711) August 29, 2022
This person conveniently left out Winn’s eight errors in 28 High-A games, so … yeah, that’s how divided this has gotten.
Would love to watch Justin Turner try to hit off of Masyn Winn pic.twitter.com/ai5rj1suk2
— Jacob (@CardinalsReek) August 29, 2022
Would you, though? Winn’s only pitched one minor-league inning this year and Turner is hitting .352 since the beginning of July.
Justin Turner has a World Series ring and he’s upset that a 20 year old 2-way prospect showed off his arm at the futures game
— Quinn (@QuinnSTLCards) August 29, 2022
OK … so now people with World Series rings can’t be upset with whatever you might deem is “beneath” them or “beyond” their concern?
Justin Turner talking shit about Winn right before saying "I don't know anything about the kid" is classic 2022.
— 𝙻𝚘𝚐𝚊𝚗 𝙼. 𝙹𝚘𝚔𝚒𝚜𝚌𝚑 (@GreytBeyond) August 29, 2022
It's also classic jealousy that he can never throw that hard.
Super glad he feels the need to give fielding advice with his zero gold gloves though! https://t.co/k0xAbTW2Qg
You had us in the first sentence. We’d all agree Turner probably shouldn’t have went in and then said, “Oh wait, I don’t even know the guy, I’m sure he’s nice and cool!” … but to say he’s “jealous” and that not having a Gold Glove excludes him from arguments that focus on defense is fairly insane.
He’s a Dodgers legend and has played third base at a well above-average clip for a long time now.
Justin Turner has faced 13 fastballs clocked in at 100+ mph this season. He has a hit off 0 of them. Not surprised he is intimidated by triple-digits.
— Ahaan Rungta (@AhaanRungta) August 29, 2022
(Per Baseball Savant, assist from @MaxSportsStudio) https://t.co/DYJZWCMCMN
Damn, OK, fine, that one’s pretty good. But all Turner was trying to do here was preach that patience, concentration and rhythm on defense takes precedent over flashiness. Winn obviously isn’t “the problem” here because he was just showcasing himself on the biggest stage yet of his career. Turner was more so focused on social media creating a bigger spectacle than it needed to.
Sadly for JT, he’s living in the past, and we all have to live with the undesirable aspects of Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and TikTok in 2022. And now he’s feeling the wrath on those platforms because of his comments, but we’re sure he doesn’t care whatsoever.

Miguel Vargas’ MLB debut with Dodgers puts pressure on Justin Turner
Top prospect Miguel Vargas made his MLB debut with the Los Angeles Dodgers on Wednesday and it's clear there's now pressure on Justin Turner.