5 unforgivable Dave Roberts moves with Dodgers that should get him fired

After a franchise-record 111 wins in the regular season, the Los Angeles Dodgers were sent home in just four games in the NLDS against the San Diego Padres. After winning Game 1 thanks in large part to a Mike Clevinger stinker, the Dodgers were thoroughly outplayed in Games 2-4 and were handed the gentleman’s sweep.

While winning 100+ games in the regular season almost every year is nice, the Dodgers have now made the playoffs every year for a decade and only have one (controversial) World Series title to show for it. With all the talent this team has possessed throughout the years, that has to be considered an underachievement.

This has led many Dodgers fans to point the finger at Dave Roberts, who has been managing the club since the 2015 campaign. While reports have already confirmed that Roberts will return next season, there are plenty of postseason mistakes in his past that are worthy of getting him fired.

In 2015, the Dodgers were torched by a nuclear Daniel Murphy, while 2016 was very obviously the Chicago Cubs’ year. However, since then, the Dodgers have been the bonafide favorites to win it all and have only done so once — often falling short because of a managerial mistake.

Let’s dive into those mistakes, in reverse chronological order.

5 most fireable decisions that Dave Roberts has made with the Dodgers:

2022 NLDS: Tommy Kahnle and the disastrous seventh inning

The seventh inning in Game 4 of the 2022 NLDS will go down in two different ways. For one fanbase, it will be a miraculous inning that finally propelled their team over their bigger brother and could potentially fuel a World Series run. For the other, it will be what many fans consider to be the breaking point.

The game simply sped up for Dave Roberts, and he could not handle it. Roberts tried stealing outs by starting the inning with Tommy Kahnle, who had just 12.2 regular-season innings since 2020. Even worse, he threw him against the exact same bats that he had faced the night before. 

That clearly blew up in the team’s face, and Roberts then went to the guy who probably should have started the inning, Yency Almonte. Almonte shouldn’t have pitched to the heart of the Padres’ order; that should have been Evan Phillips.

Then, with Jake Cronenworth due up and the game on the line, Roberts rushed Alex Vesia into the game without giving him a proper warm-up (and with a 1-0 count on the batter!). It was a disaster, and was entirely avoidable.

Almonte should have started the seventh against the bottom of the order. Evan Phillips could have pitched the eighth against the heart of the order assuming Almonte had a clean seventh, and then the Dodgers could have deployed their secret weapon — Dustin May — in the ninth.

Ah, what could have been.

2019 NLDS: Bringing Clayton Kershaw out of the bullpen

The blown lead in the seventh inning against the Padres in 2022 feels awfully similar to the blown lead in the eighth inning in the 2019 NLDS against the Washington Nationals. Both games were absolutely winnable for the Los Angeles Dodgers, and Roberts putting in the wrong pitcher at the wrong time is ultimately what lost the game.

In the case of 2019, Roberts once again tried to recapture the magic from a previous decision and went with Clayton Kershaw out of the bullpen. It worked in the 2018 NLCS, so it had to work in the 2019 NLDS, right?

Every decision is different, and while it may have worked one year, that does not guarantee it will work another year against a completely different opponent.

To be fair, the decision did initially seem to pay off, as Kershaw came into the game in the top of the seventh in a high-leverage spot and was able to strike out Adam Eaton.

But that is where Kershaw’s outing should have ended. Instead of trusting his bullpen to get the final six outs, Roberts left Kershaw out there against the two best hitters in the Nationals’ lineup. Anthony Rendon and Juan Soto made him pay for that decision, hitting back-to-back home runs on back-to-back pitches.

Just like 2022, the offense was in too much shock to overcome this jarring series of events, allowing the game to go to extra innings, where Howie Kendrick delivered the final blow with a grand slam.

2018 World Series: Pulling Rich Hill too early (and over-relying on Ryan Madson)

If there is one mistake that stands out above the rest, it is Dave Roberts’ decision to pull Rich Hill in Game 4 of the 2018 World Series. Looking back at the 2018 World Series, it may not seem like a big deal, as the Dodgers ended up losing in five games.

While nothing is guaranteed, if the Dodgers would have won this game, then they would have been in a great position to rally and win the series. Boston’s pitching staff was seriously depleted, and if the series had gone past five games, Los Angeles would undoubtedly have had the advantage.

Winning Game 4 would have swung the momentum and would have put Boston in a tough spot. Instead, the Dodgers lost Game 4 and it completely changed the complexion of the series, allowing Boston to ride David Price (and closer Chris Sale) in Game 5 to a victory.

Rich Hill pitched the best game of his Dodgers career, and Dave Roberts pulled him in favor of another left-handed pitcher, Scott Alexander. Alexander lasted just one batter. The Dodgers went from having all of the momentum behind a dominant Hill performance and a three-run home run by Yasiel Puig to having their backs against the wall.

Roberts then followed up his Hill mistake with another mistake in putting Ryan Madson in. Madson was awful in the regular season and had a few good outings before the World Series. He then became the team’s chosen high-leverage reliever despite allowing all of his inherited runners to score in Games 1-3.

Roberts went to Madson again and Madson allowed a three-run bomb to Mitch Moreland. While the Dodgers still led at the time, every fan knew it was over then.

2017 World Series: Not pulling the plug on Yu Darvish sooner

There is a lot of revisionist history with Game 7 of the 2017 World Series. In hindsight, most Dodgers fans are outraged at the team’s decision to start Yu Darvish over Clayton Kershaw. Fans, of course, are saying that because Darvish was shelled and Kershaw came in and pitched perfectly in relief.

Starting Darvish was the right decision. Kershaw was on short rest and was coming off of a Game 5 in which Houston punished him at the plate (at the time, we didn’t know they were banging trash cans to do so!). The Dodgers traded for Darvish literally for this moment, as they desperately needed another big-game pitcher.

Where the mistake lies is Roberts not having a quick enough hook in a do-or-die game. This is something Roberts has gotten better at, but it unfortunately has led to him having too quick of a hook on occasion, such as when he pulled Tyler Anderson in Game 4 of the 2022 NLDS.

With the way Darvish was pitching, he never should have been given the chance to face George Springer a second time. If Roberts is one batter quicker in using Brandon Morrow, then the game could have stayed at 3-0, and who knows? Maybe the bats would not have been as demoralized, and could have put more pressure on Houston’s pitching staff.

While it might not seem to matter in a game where the Dodgers only scored one run, that home run gave the Astros a comfortable enough lead where the tying run never came to the plate. That changed the complexion of the rest of the game.

3 Dodgers free agents who definitely won’t be back in 2023

The Los Angeles Dodgers 2022 season has ended. Now it's time for free agency and roster turnover. Don't expect these guys to return in 2023.

And who knows, if Roberts pulls Darvish after the first inning it would have just been 2-0, and then everything changes.