3 destinations for Cody Bellinger if Dodgers non-tender him

1 of 3

Today’s the day! By the end of Friday, Dodgers fans will know if the team opted to bring 2019 MVP Cody Bellinger back at a suddenly-exorbitant price for one more season, or if they chose to let him explore the market (while potentially keeping contact with him on side channels about a discount).

Man. Imagine waking up a Dodgers fan who went into a coma in 2019, and showing them this? They’d probably say, “Wait, the 2020 season was how many games long?!”

Early indications have been the Dodgers would like Bellinger to return, which is somewhat surprising given his cost and back-to-back years as a black hole in the lineup. He’s among the most tantalizing names in the current game, though, right alongside 2022 teammate Joey Gallo.

It doesn’t take a soothsayer to visualize an unlocked version of Bellinger, either. He slammed 47 home runs with a 1.035 OPS/167 OPS+ in 2019, striking out a remarkably low 108 times in 558 at-bats. Hell, he even recovered from his porous 2021 to tomahawk a high fastball into the right-field seats for a game-tying home run against the Braves in the NLCS, briefly rendering his 1.0-WAR-subtracting, .165-hitting season irrelevant.

And yet, there’s Bellinger, rightly ranked among MLB’s other non-tender candidates after two remarkably poor seasons.

The Dodgers are rightly nervous about what Bellinger could produce if they’re the foolish ones to finally let him go, but we’re going on three years now of production that ranges from “Pretty Bad Bellinger” to “The Absolute Dregs.”

If LA backtracks on their initial impulses and lets Belli walk ahead of free agency — a payday that won’t be coming in Hollywood — these three teams should be in play for the reclamation project.

3 MLB teams that could add Cody Bellinger if Dodgers non-tender him

Cody Bellinger #35 of the Los Angeles Dodgers (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images) /

3. Chicago Cubs

All indications are the Cubs are ready to get back into the high-end free agent bidding process this offseason — which means they can also bid on Cody Bellinger!

Kidding, of course, but signing potential breakouts who are just a tweak away is what middling rosters like the Cubs typically do. Add in Chicago’s excess money in this particular offseason, and they might have a slight advantage over all the other Sabermetric squads trying to get Bellinger rejuvenated.

The Cubs showed a willingness to live on the financial edge already this offseason when they released Jason Heyward and absorbed a $22 million loss. While no one wants to throw good money after bad, that maneuver shows the current Cubs are unafraid to take a risk in the name of roster betterment after several years of piecing non-competitive teams together.

This time around, Chicago’s reportedly among the leaders for shortstop Carlos Correa after spending heavily last offseason to lure Japanese import Seiya Suzuki to man right field at Wrigley. Combined with the emergence of 2022 All-Star Ian Happ in left, the Cubs are a center fielder away from a pretty solid outfield picture.

Bellinger may never be the 2019 vintage ever again, but rest assured, there will be plenty of pseudo-contenders linked to him the second he hits the open market. If he’s interested in leaving Cal for the Ivy League, the Cubs make sense.

Cody Bellinger #35 of the Los Angeles Dodgers (Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images) /

2. New York Mets

Now, if we’re talking about contenders who can afford the financial risk in case Bellinger never slingshots back to the top of the MVP conversation, the Mets are No. 1 with a bullet. They’re also No. 1 with a center field vacancy, considering incumbent Brandon Nimmo is more than likely going to chase the money and depart Citi Field.

Nimmo spent the past few years remaking himself as both a durable cog and an impressive defender, but Bellinger’s instincts for the position are a little more natural. Belli’s value depends almost entirely on his ability to mash between 20-25 homers, though; without the bat snapping back to reality, he might as well be a $17 million Kevin Kiermaier.

The Mets are one of very few teams in the Dodgers’ stratosphere who could afford to pay Bellinger an escalated salary on the oft chance he returns to MVP form. Surely, their lurking presence is one reason the Dodgers are so hesitant to part ways with their slugger, even though they know they’re unlikely to turn back the clock by keeping him.

If they non-tender Bellinger, he’s not going to an also-ran. He’s going to a team the Dodgers will likely see standing in their way come October.

If Steve Cohen really does want to be Dodgers East, he could do worse than throwing a lawn dart at a suddenly-loose Bellinger. Might want to move in those right-center field fences even further, though.

Aaron Judge #99 of the New York Yankees and Cody Bellinger #35 of the Los Angeles Dodgers (Photo by Brace Hemmelgarn/Minnesota Twins/Getty Images) /

1. New York Yankees

Come on! You had to see this coming. Bellinger to the Yankees has long been a sarcastic comment in the Twitterverse that’s so crazy it just might work.

Now, it’s more realistic than ever — and just a few weeks before Twitter implodes, too. Fitting.

Adding a reclamation project rarely comes with this much upside, but it would also be perfectly understandable if Yankees fans were frustrated by a hypothetical Bellinger move. The slugger’s stock has never been lower (well, maybe after 2021), and adding the ex-Dodger would just be a variation on the team’s typical playbook. Sure, he’s younger. Sure, his peak was higher than most. But bringing Bellinger in still reeks of “Now! That’s What I Call Baseball 2019,” especially now that center field defense is being ably handled by Harrison Bader.

Bellinger in left, Bader in center, Judge (theoretically) in right? If Judge doesn’t return, he could be … replaced by Bellinger, and might bolt for the Dodgers himself? It’s a less than ideal scenario for Yankee fans, but you have to imagine Brian Cashman has been just as seduced by Bellinger as Andrew Friedman has.

And that’s why it probably won’t happen after all. Because he’s staying. He’s staying, right?

Home / Dodgers Rumors

3 MLB teams that could add Cody Bellinger if Dodgers non-tender him

3. Chicago Cubs

2. New York Mets

1. New York Yankees

Schedule