Dodgers have to move on after 2026 despite Max Muncy’s plea to stay

The Los Angeles Dodgers' picking up Max Muncy's $10 million option for 2026 was one of the least surprising moves that will happen this offseason. Despite the struggles Muncy had to open the season, as well as the Alex Bregman and Nolan Arenado rumors that have persisted in recent years, Muncy's turn to glasses revived his offensive approach, and he added to his October legacy during the World Series against the Toronto Blue Jays.

Much like Miguel Rojas returning to Los Angeles, even if they did overpay him, it just made sense for Muncy to be back in 2026. While Rojas has already confirmed that 2026 will be his final season as a player, Muncy has different desires.

While appearing as a guest on Foul Territory, talking about his history of extensions with the Dodgers, Muncy did express hope to work out a new deal with Andrew Friedman and Co. to allow him to remain a Dodger beyond next season. Muncy suggested that once the heavy lifting is done in the offseason, perhaps the two sides can potentially work out a new deal before he hits free agency next winter.

Max Muncy is already making the case for a new deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers

No offense to Muncy and the heroics he has had for the Dodgers over the last eight years, but the end of the line is approaching. To his credit, after a dreadful showing to start the season, Muncy finished 2025 with a wRC+ of 137 and 19 home runs. That's the reason why it made sense for the Dodgers to bring him back at the lowly cost of $10 million, but he will be turning 36 before the end of next season.

Rather than bring Muncy back, 2026 should serve as his farewell tour in Los Angeles. He doesn't have to retire, but he certainly shouldn't be the Dodgers' starting third baseman come 2027 (and beyond).

Besides, the reality is that for as great as the Dodgers' World Series run has been over the last two years, their core is only getting older. Letting Muncy walk while clearing an opening at third base for Alex Freeland would be an easy way for the Dodgers to usher in some of their top prospects, while also having money to spend elsewhere.

There's also the reality the Dodgers can keep Muncy as a veteran bench option while chasing a more high-profile name at third base so they can begin their next dynastic chapter. Whatever the approach, don't expect any contract extension to anoint Muncy the starter after the curtains drop on 2026.