5 Dodgers trade candidates from teams quickly falling out of contention

Paul Blackburn

The Reds may be bad and poorly run, but the Oakland Athletics have taken being terrible to performance art levels in 2023, as they continue to try and force a move to Las Vegas by fielding a team that wouldn't be favored against many Triple-A clubs. Their stadium is falling apart and infested with various fauna and the roster ... matches it well.

On the surface, Paul Blackburn does not seem like a great fit right now, as he has yet to play in 2023 after he suffered an injury to his fingernail before the season started and developed a blister during a rehab start. That will delay his debut further. He has also only been okay in his career, with his All-Star nod being almost solely because SOMEONE had to represent Oakland there. He also has the added benefit of not having a ton of miles on his arm yet, as he has thrown just 249.1 innings in his career.

However, he has been relatively steady and has some team control, which could be appealing. More importantly, he is an Oakland A's player, which seemingly means that Oakland is likely willing to give him away at the drop of a hat so they don't have to pay anymore of his already miniscule salary. The Dodgers should ask about top prospect Mason Miller, but Blackburn seems like a safer bet to get moved by the A's, even if that isn't sexy.

Alexis Diaz

We are circling back to the Reds yet again because, despite their best efforts, they have still managed to collect some actual talent on their roster. It is actually comical how poorly run and uncompetitive the Reds are year in, year out. Their own owner BEFORE THE SEASON even had a slideshow identifying the Reds as having no chance of making the playoffs each year since 2019. It is very related that said owner's comments (and others like them) have made him decidedly unpopular amongst the Reds fanbase.

However, back to the actual players, Alexis Diaz is getting the nod here, and with good reason, as he would be a big jolt for the Dodgers' bullpen. Through 13 appearances so far this season, Diaz has a 2.45 ERA with 21 strikeouts in 11 innings of work. His fastball/slider combo play off each other well, and he is very hard to impact the ball against. In short, he is a very, very good reliever with high quality stuff that you can run out there confidently in high-leverage situations.

The problem here is that he won't even see his first arbitration hearing until after the 2025 season, so acquiring him could be very pricey with that amount of team control. The Reds may not be good at fielding a team that can win actual baseball games, but they can at least understand that they have a player with value in Diaz. That said, an elite reliever on a team like the Reds, which could be bad for a while, is like having new leather seats in a 1997 Dodge Neon that has skipped a couple oil changes in its lifetime while its paint fades. Relievers are also very volatile in general, so the Dodgers may be able to swing something if the package was rich enough, as it is possible Diaz's value may never be higher for the Reds.

David Bednar

Look, I know that the Pirates were a really fun story to start the season, as they somehow took a team of cheap spare parts and young talent and catapulted into first place in the NL Central. Sure, the Pirates' ownership has been the poster child for teams with rich owners that cry poor and refuse to invest in their rosters, but it was nice to believe for a bit that those players could run back the script of Major League and make some noise.

Unfortunately, the news lately from them hasn't been nearly as good, and it seems likely that they will be out of contention as we approach the trade deadline, even in a division as poor as the NL Central. That brings us to David Bednar, who compares favorably, at least in terms of value, to the aforementioned Diaz. Bednar is having another excellent season so far, with an 0.64 ERA and 19 strikeouts in 14 innings of work.

Relievers are always going to be in demand, and that isn't just speaking of the Dodgers, so Pittsburgh is going to be getting a lot of calls about Bednar. He has a little less team control than Diaz, but that also means that he has more of a track record of performance, which could be enticing if the Dodgers decide they want to make a big play for a closer at the deadline to bolster the bullpen. It is unclear if the Pirates would actually move a guy like Bednar, though, because the team IS more interesting than it has been in a while and Bednar could serve as the backbone of the bullpen (and hometown Pittsburgh hero) for several years at minimal cost.

Shohei Ohtani

Yeah, you probably knew this one was coming, as Shohei Ohtani is going to be the most watched name on the trade market this year, given that he is about to hit free agency and make a HUGE sum of money that could be in excess of $600 million. It is not hyperbole to say that there is not a player like him on the market (as in, one player). He would instantly become most teams' best hitter and best pitcher in one roster spot. He is doing things that we haven't seen since before World War II and it is beautiful.

We'll start with the reasons why this could happen. First, he is incredibly good, as he has slashed .294/.362/.515 this season with seven homers, while also posting a 2.74 ERA with 66 strikeouts in 46 innings of work on the mound. He has won a Rookie of the Year and an MVP award already, and had a really good case to win AL MVP last year, when he finished second. Also, he is on an Angels team that is currently kinda competing, but has a poor track record of actually finishing a complete season well and stands to lose Ohtani for just a draft pick if they don't trade him. Finally, the Dodgers have long been rumored to sign Ohtani and it sounds like the feeling is very mutual, so there would be an opportunity for LA to get an exclusive extension negotiation window before the season ends (and before other bidders can enter the fray).

There are some issues here, though. First, even though the trade would technically be for a rental since Ohtani's contract is up at the end of the season, he is still going to be very expensive in trade capital. Again, there isn't another player out there that gives you the sort of 2 for 1 value that he does, even if it is only for half a season's worth of value.

More importantly, the Dodgers seem more likely to try to get under the luxury tax by the end of the season to reset their penalties so that signing Ohtani in the offseason is more feasible/less painful. They could, in theory, shed a big chunk of change ahead of time via other trades to make room for the remainder of Ohtani's contract in 2023 and still make that plan work, but that could be easier said than done, unless the Dodgers part with some good players to make it worthwhile to other teams.