Skip to main content

It sure seems like Kyle Tucker’s awful contract is preventing Dodgers from making Tarik Skubal play

Maybe $60 million per year was a sliiight overpay...
ByColin Keane
Kyle Tucker.
Kyle Tucker. | Aaron Gash/GettyImages

Believe it or not, the Los Angeles Dodgers are reportedly on the outside looking in when it comes to the Tarik Skubal sweepstakes. The latest information from top MLB insiders Buster Olney and Jeff Passan suggests that the New York Mets and the Toronto Blue Jays -- not the Dodgers -- are at the front of the line for Skubal.

How did we get here? Aren't the Dodgers supposed to be the big, bad dynasty with all the money in the world to spend? How are they being outbid for Skubal?

While it's a bit more complicated than that (Andrew Friedman doesn't like giving long-term mega-deals to players entering or nearing their 30s), it's also not. You see, the Dodgers dole out massive contracts from time to time, but they committed to an offseason of gargantuan expenditures last season. Remember how much money they gave to Kyle Tucker?

Dodgers' historically huge Kyle Tucker contract set them up to miss out on Tarik Skubal

Tucker's four-year, $240 million contract looked like a clear overpay in the moment, and now it looks even worse. Tucker severely underwhelmed in 2026, hitting .233/.330/.385 with 17 home runs. His barrel rate and hard-hit rate plummeted from the prior year.

If the Dodgers could go back and avoid signing Tucker, thereby freeing up that $240 million to contribute toward Skubal's estimated $400 million-ish contract ... would they? You bet. Even though the Dodgers' insistence that their rotation is all set has become the PR-fed reason for them to sit out the Skubal sweepstakes, there's more to the story than that. This is the Dodgers we're talking about. Stacking aces is what they've always been interested in doing under Friedman's watch.

With a new CBA looming in the nearby shadows, adding a colossal Skubal deal to Tucker's (on top of LA's huge payroll beyond those two) wouldn't be prudent at this point, not even for the ultra-aggressive Dodgers who are desperate to return to championship glory in 2027.

A three-peat was clearly their "endgame" in the sense that a Skubal rental made sense. Had LA won their third title in a row this year, that rental would've looked genius, just as Skubal's inevitable departure would've seemed like a moot point. It was a good gamble. Skubal's that special. Now, we're dealing with the offseason aftermath that Friedman must've seen coming; it's just an aftermath that would've tasted so much more palatable with a successful three-peat in the rearview.

Friedman can still surprise us all. Perhaps he'll throw caution to the wind (as he's been known to do) and end up with Skubal anyway. Whatever happens, the reality about Tucker remains: So far, he's been a mistake of a signing at that price. And the consequences go beyond his disappointing production alone.

Add us as a preferred source on Google