Right-hander Dustin May has been in the MLB headlines a lot recently, which has Los Angeles Dodgers fans thinking back to his time with LA before the organization traded him.
In a 2025 deadline deal, the Dodgers sent May to a desperate Boston Red Sox team in exchange for prospects James Tibbs III and Zach Ehrhard. Tibbs was a top-5 organizational prospect at the time, and he's continued to show his quality in the Dodgers' system, hitting .287/.409/.532 with 30 home runs and 107 RBI for Triple-A Oklahoma City in 2026.
Tibbs' production, paired with May's inconsistent form with the Red Sox and, later, the St. Louis Cardinals (with whom May had great outings as well as awful ones), always made Dodgers fans feel like they won the trade.
Dodgers fans have never regretted losing Dustin May
May performing decently for the Milwaukee Brewers and collecting another World Series ring didn't necessarily make Dodgers fans change their tune about him. At the end of the day, the Dodgers version of Dustin May never found his footing, and that is his legacy in Los Angeles. He left behind an 18-16 record in a six-year tenure that featured plenty of missed time due to two Tommy John surgeries and an esophageal tear.
However, neither May's history of inconsistency nor his injury troubles dissuaded the Chicago White Sox from giving May a big bag of money this week. Chicago agreed to a three-year contract with the right-hander worth $52.5 million.
May never stayed healthy enough for Dodgers fans to appreciate him, which is why it makes sense that they are collectively scratching their heads at the White Sox's investment. Surely, Chicago is looking at the fact that May cleared 130 innings pitched in each of the last two seasons, taking it as a sign that his durability struggles are in the rearview.
Dodgers fans will offer a rebuttal to that theory by pointing out that May has pitched for no less than four different organizations during that two-year span. Essentially, if the guy is worth middle-of-the-rotation money, why is he being passed around from club to club?
The White Sox are betting that May's relative youth (29 years old) and undeniable velocity will win out in the end. Meanwhile, naysayers (Dodgers fans among them) are at the ready to remind Chicago that May still suffers from command issues from time to time, not to mention the residual effects of his multiple surgeries.
If May's command and body stay sturdy in Chicago, maybe the White Sox will surprisingly have the last laugh here. In that outcome, Dodgers fans will be back to wondering how May's career in LA might've gone differently if he'd stayed healthy. For now, though, they're totally convinced this was a big overpay by the White Sox.
