Kiké Hernández
All of LA loves Kiké Hernández, but he's another player the Dodgers should sever ties with. The Dodgers' bench has been a problem the entire season, but Hernández and Chris Taylor as their two go-to utility guys was an especially bleak duo in the regular season. Hernández has been a lot better than Taylor (almost everyone has been better than Taylor), but his .229 average and .654 OPS during the regular season isn't enough for the Dodgers to sign him for another year.
Although he returned to his usual, uncanny postseason god status in October, the Dodgers might finally have a real shot at Willy Adames in his free agency, and Bo Bichette will be out there as a potential Plan B. Miguel Rojas has been the Dodgers' primary shortstop since Nick Ahmed was DFA'ed in August, but even if the Dodgers exercise their club option on Rojas for 2025, it's unlikely that he'll be an everyday guy again next year. That would fill the bench with him, Taylor, Austin Barnes, and Andy Pages.
Even if the Dodgers dump Rojas, that shouldn't guarantee Hernández's spot on the bench. We can look back on the banana suit antics fondly, but still be looking to upgrade for 2025.
Jack Flaherty
Flaherty is the only Dodger here who does have a pretty good shot of returning based on his entire season. Because he split his time between two teams this year, he's ineligible to receive the qualifying offer, so he'll go back out to free agency looking for a three- or four-year deal. The Dodgers do have the leg up here — Flaherty performed well enough after the trade deadline, vibes well with the team, and is an LA native who grew up rooting for the Dodgers — but it wouldn't be surprising if he hears offers from a few other teams before making a decision.
He's going to have multiple teams on his tail, too. It wouldn't be altogether surprising if the Tigers approach him again, and Flaherty made it clear on social media that he was still following and rooting for that team during their improbable playoff run. He's also been identified as a good fit for the Red Sox and Mets, but it's likely a couple more clubs will also make some calls about him.
Provided everyone is healthy by the start of the next season, the Dodgers rotation also already looks rather complete as it is. Tyler Glasnow, Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Shohei Ohtani, Tony Gonsolin, and Clayton Kershaw (probably) are all in the mix. Although they have some flexibility with Gonsolin, who still has minor-league options or could theoretically be turned into a reliever, neither a demotion to the minors nor to the bullpen seems likely.
So this is a toss-up. Flaherty will have a lot of options during his free agency, and the Dodgers need to figure out if they even need another starter at all.