Looking ahead to 2027, one of the biggest questions facing the Los Angeles Dodgers is what role super prospect Josue De Paula can play for the club. De Paula's September showing was short, but impactful. The 21-year-old only played 11 games, but with 11 walks against five strikeouts and a .323/.500/.581 line, he had folks dreaming about his postseason impact.
The Dodgers did, in fact, decide to carry De Paula on the playoff roster, and it further fueled his 2027 hype. However, while there are many who would like to see Los Angeles trade away Teoscar Hernandez, there are some serious concerns about De Paula's defense that could be exposed over a 162-game workload.
As good as De Paula has been, and a sizzling .303/.401/.547 line with 27 homers down in Tulsa proves that the hype is warranted; he might not be the best fit for the Dodgers' 2027 roster. As currently constructed, the lineup doesn't give him a pathway to regular playing time, and even if he did, the defensive issues are a problem not only on the field but also for his future.
What LA actually needs is a better roster fit, and if they're looking for a prospect to give them a depth boost, then the answer isn't De Paula but instead is James Tibbs III.
James Tibbs III, not Josue De Paula, is the prospect who should get first crack at the Dodgers' 2027 Opening Day roster
While De Paula gets most of the attention, it should be noted that Tibbs is no slouch in his own right. The 24-year-old hit .287/.409/.532 with 30 dingers at Oklahoma City this year, but that wasn't the end of his impressive story. Tibbs, along with Andrew Fischer in the Milwaukee Brewers' system, became the first player in the minors to tally 100-plus walks, RBI, and runs in a single season since 2005.
Tibbs is no joke, and that alone makes him worthy of more consideration. However, there are other, more practical reasons as to why he'd be a better choice than De Paula to break camp with the 2027 Dodgers.
For one, he's nearly three years older than De Paula and just completed a full Triple-A campaign. De Paula went straight from Double-A to the majors this September, and hasn't played a single game at the minors' highest level. He'd no doubt benefit from logging some time in Oklahoma City, if only to work on his defense in a lower-pressure environment.
Both youngsters are left-handed hitters, but if Los Angeles wants a lefty platoon bat, the prospect who fits the bill is Tibbs. LA's No. 7 prospect is regarded by most as the strongside of a platoon as his ceiling. The job that is seemingly up for grabs is more in Tibbs' wheelhouse by that assessment, and De Paula's growth would certainly be stunted if he only played against righties, since he'd stay down in Oklahoma City getting regular at-bats.
On top of that, Tibbs is a more versatile player, and that's what the Dodgers need. In addition to playing the outfield, Tibbs has experience playing first base. Freeman turned 37 in September and was banged up at points in 2026. Having a player who can give the aging star a breather and fill in at first in case of a Freeman injury would be a huge boost.
At the end of the day, the goal is to build the best roster where all of the pieces fit together in 2027, while maximizing the long-term value of assets. To that end, Tibbs has more present value given the current iteration of the Dodgers' roster, and De Paula carries the most hope for the future on his shoulders. Barring some sort of stunning development, it only makes sense to carry Tibbs over De Paula with the big league squad in 2027.
