The Los Angeles Dodgers hadn't gone without at least one Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger winner since 2021, but the streak was broken on Tuesday, when FanSided announced this year's honorees on The Baseball Insiders podcast.
The National League team award went to the Chicago Cubs, the NL DH award went to Kyle Schwarber, and the NL third baseman award went to Alex Bregman.
We'll make no arguments as to the Cubs' win over the Dodgers, nor Schwarber's over Ohtanis, but Bregman over Muncy is certainly arguable. They had incredibly comparable offensive seasons; Bregman only really ran away in RBI, but Muncy had the edge in OPS.
Muncy is a multi-time finalist, but may be doomed to a 'bridesmaid but never the bride' fate. Since Silver Slugger started announcing finalists in 2021, Muncy has missed out just twice in 2022 and 2024. He lost out to then-Atlanta Brave Freddie Freeman at first base in 2021, the Braves' Austin Riley in 2023, the San Diego Padres' Manny Machado in 2025, and now Bregman in 2026.
And he might be running low on chances. Muncy is 36 and entering the last guaranteed year of his contract with the Dodgers.
Dodgers don't have a Silver Slugger winner for the first time since 2021 after Max Muncy was snubbed
On a team full of superstars, Muncy is not only one of the Dodgers' longest-tenured players but perhaps their most underrated. He's the all-time leader in home runs at Dodger Stadium and posted 3.0 bWAR in just 73 games in an injury-abbreviated 2024 season. He's averaged just over 26 homers per season for the Dodgers since they picked him up off the Athletics' scrapheap in 2017.
He's a three-time All-Star and three-time MVP votes recipient ... but he's never won a Silver Slugger. Something about that just doesn't compute.
Freeman was otherworldly in 2021, Riley the better all-around bat in 2023, Machado played in 159 games in 2025 to Muncy's 100 that year. But Muncy vs. Bregman may be the most evenly matched head-to-head battle we've seen yet. Apparently, Bregman just had that much more of an edge.
But Muncy is nothing if not consistent — if anything, he's gotten better with age. This season, he played in 49 more games and hit 10 more home runs than he did in 2025. He's dealt with some injuries over the past few years, but if he can stay healthy next season, it might be his year.
