Kiké Hernandez surgery puts Dodgers in a tough spot for 2026 reunion

Kiké Hernández hasn't always been with the Los Angeles Dodgers since debuting in 2014, but he's felt like a Los Angeles institution ever since he played his first game for the team back in 2015.

He's had so many memorable moments in a Dodgers uniform. Remember that three-home performance to win the pennant in 2017? And with three rings to his name, he's been an integral part of the current dynasty.

However, news struck that Hernández had surgery on his left elbow after the Dodgers' triumph this year, which will undoubtedly impact his 2026 campaign in some capacity. There's no current timetable for his return, but he has already confirmed that he doesn't plan on being ready to play for Puerto Rico in the 2026 World Baseball Classic in March.

So, that naturally leads to a difficult question: Should the Dodgers foresake an offseason roster spot (and some payroll space) in order to keep Hernández around?

Kiké Hernández dilemma could reveal Dodgers' free agency plans

Because of his injury and sentimental attachment to the Dodgers, there's no rush for Hernández to find a home for 2026. It's unlikely the 34-year-old, who hasn't possessed an above-average bat since 2021, will be met with a swath of suitors anyway.

However, after playing 2025 on a one-year, $6.5 million deal and nabbing 16 hits in the postseason, his championship experience and clubhouse leadership is simply invaluable. A similar contract for 2026 could in the cards if the Dodgers really value his intangibles and versatility.

It's worth pointing out that retaining Hernández would require the Dodgers to use a 40-man roster spot until the 60-day injured list becomes available again (usually right before Opening Day). Of course, Los Angeles could wait out the market and let him linger in free agency, but that may create some unnecessary ill will, especially as he rehabs an injury he played through just to help the team win another World Series title. Then again, they could arrive at a good faith agreement in which LA promises to sign him when the 60-day IL designation can be used.

Of course, that roster spot could be used on another free agent who is more likely to contribute across the entirety of the 2026 campaign, and it's simply a matter of fact that Hernández derives most of his value from playing practically every position on the diamond at an average level. His 70 wRC+ this year was his lowest since 2016, but it hasn't been above 100 since 2021. Likewise, he was worth negative fWAR this year for the second time in three seasons.

There's so much sentimentality tied up here that it feels impossible to let Hernández go. He's a fiery presence who brings infectious energy to the ballpark every day. But, staring down a long rehab process and waning effectiveness at the plate, it may be time for the Dodgers to move on from their cult hero.