Dream Dodgers starting lineup for the 2024 season

Without question, this offseason has a lot on the line for the Los Angeles Dodgers. Not only are they coming off another disappointing playoff exit, but their rotation is also looking very iffy going into 2024, especially if Clayton Kershaw can't come back from injury, and they could hand out the biggest contract in baseball history if they land Shohei Ohtani.

That is a lot of known unknowns for a team that has grown accustomed to being the class of the National League. There is a world, though, where everything breaks their way and they look like a juggernaut once again. What could the Dodgers' lineup look like if they did not care at all about their payroll and pushed their chips in for 2024?

Here's the dream 2024 Dodgers lineup

The idea here is simple: build the ideal Dodgers lineup using existing Dodgers players as well as available free agents. Trades are bit too hard to account for here and the logical step if they are included would be to build an All-Star team out of players that are very, very much not available in trade. That said, using just this free agent class could result in a lineup that would strike fear in just about any team. Let's take a look.

Batting first, Mookie Betts - RF

When you have a top two MVP candidate already batting leadoff, it is best not to mess with a good thing. Mookie Betts' 2023 season was truly special. Not only did he have to play half the season in the infield because the Dodgers desperately needed him to, but he did it well while also posting a 167 wRC+ and .987 OPS at the plate. If not for an historic season from the Braves' Ronald Acuña Jr., Mookie would have been the runaway MVP this year (and he still has a slim shot despite everything that transpired).

As for lineup construction, Mookie is a great option regardless of whether one prefers to just bat your best hitter first or to stick with traditional lineup roles. Mookie can run, he gets on base at a high clip, and he can impact games in a variety of different ways. He gets a break from his infield duties here, plays right every day, and probably will be a top 5-10 player in MLB again next season at minimum.

Batting second, Freddie Freeman - 1B

Freddie Freeman got a bit of a raw deal in 2023. Most of the time over the last decade, putting up a .331/.410/.567 line with 29 homers, 23 steals (still not sure how that happened), and a league-leading doubles total would make a guy an MVP favorite. Acuña Jr. and Betts were just THAT good in 2023, but that doesn't take away from what Freddie accomplished, and the Dodgers certainly have to be feeling good for getting Freddie away from the Braves right now.

Freddie's left-handed bat was a staple in the #2 spot for LA all season long and, again, there is no reason to mess with what works here. Some consideration to alternating handedness in the lineup is going to be given for this list, but keeping Freeman where he excelled all season long works out great for that as well.

Batting third, Will Smith - C

Placing guys in ideal lineup spots gets harder from here on in, but Will Smith was really good in the No. 3 spot and gives the Dodgers a righty bat after Freeman. Weirdly enough, Smith's best career numbers on a rate basis came when he was batting sixth and especially eighth. However, those were pretty small samples, and he has been great as the three hole hitter overall.

It was nice to see Smith get some love and be named to his first All-Star Game in 2023. Overall, he slashed .261/.359/.438 with 19 homers and accumulated 4.1 rWAR this past season. In a vacuum, that is strong production. At catcher, it is almost a miracle to see that at the plate. Smith may not have the same upside as others in the lineup, but having him at No. 3 lengthens LA's lineup considerably while sacrificing little in the way of production.

Batting fourth, Shohei Ohtani - DH

Alright, this is where things get fun. It is the worst kept secret, if it is a secret at all, that the Dodgers are going to be making a run at signing Ohtani this offseason. LA reset their luxury tax penalties and arranged their entire payroll to be able to be in the running for his services. It isn't hard to see why they would be so motivated to nab him, as he is a once-in-a-generation talent that, in theory, is a frontline starter and top flight power bat all rolled up in one player.

The only issue here is Ohtani's injury and how it could impact how big his final contract ends up being. We don't care about money for this list whatsoever, but it is fair to wonder just how high the Dodgers ($) are actually willing to go for Shohei, especially since he won't be pitching at all in 2024. This also isn't his first elbow injury, and that has to be a little spooky (and is one reason why he is only hitting fourth in this lineup).

Batting fifth, Jorge Soler - LF

Going into the offseason, one area of need for the lineup is someone to play left field. LA made it work in 2023 rotating Chris Taylor, David Peralta, and others in left, but the results left a bit to be desired. For this lineup, turning to the free agent pool and looking for a right-handed masher that could spell Ohtani at DH as he gets full healthy is the plan, and Jorge Soler fits the bit perfectly.

Soler's 2022 season in Miami was not great and he was banged up, but he turned things around in 2023 in a big way with an .853 OPS in 580 plate appearances with 36 home runs. Soler just obliterates baseballs, plain and simple. He is not a perfect hitter and will definitely never be in the running for a batting title, but he does draw some walks and can take over games single-handedly. For a No. 5 hitter, he would be an absolute luxury.

Batting sixth, Max Muncy - 3B

The Dodgers are going to be paying Max Muncy $7 million next season before having to realistically start thinking about any decisions about his future in LA down the line. However, assuming he can remember how to post a batting average a bit further north of .200 next season, even his $10 million club option for 2026 could look like a steal, and his power from the left side will be perfect behind Soler here.

With only Matt Chapman being remotely interesting from the free agent market, and the fact that Chapman cratered in the second half at the plate in 2023, we'll stick with Muncy for now. He still walks a ton, and having a guy who is basically a lock to hit 35+ homers in the sixth spot in the lineup has a ton of value. This decision could go south, especially if Max's hit tool issues get worse, but there is too much upside here to pass up.

Batting seventh, James Outman - CF

Some consideration here needs to be given to the future, and it sure seems like James Outman is going to be a big part of the next several years for the Dodgers. Having back to back lefties in the lineup isn't "ideal" per se, but the free agent market for right-handed centerfielders is pretty abysmal, and Outman showed a lot of promise in 2023 after dominating in the minor leagues during the 2022 season.

The youngster did tail off a bit for LA as the 2023 season went on after a hot start, but no one should be upset about a rookie season where he hit 23 homers and posted a .790 OPS. The crazy thing is that he hasn't come close to reaching his potential at the plate yet, and his nine Outs Above Average in the outfield give the Dodgers two plus or better defenders out there when you include Mookie in right everyday.