It's totally understandable why the Los Angeles Dodgers would want to reset their payroll to avoid paying a hefty luxury tax, especially if the rumors are true that they plan to hand Shohei Ohtani a blank check next offseason.
But that doesn't mean some of the decisions along the way haven't been questionable ... or at least worthy of a greater explanation. The latest pertains to Justin Turner, who signed with the Boston Red Sox on Sunday night after agreeing to a two-year deal just over $20 million.
The Dodgers rejecting Turner's $16 million team option to potentially bring him back for less was another business decision fans could get behind. But signing JD Martinez to a one-year, $10 million contract and letting Turner walk for ~$10 million per year (there's an opt-out clause for the 2024 season in his deal with Boston) didn't really make sense.
Nor did letting Tyler Anderson leave for the LA Angels on a three-year, $39 million contract ($13 million per season) and then signing Noah Syndergaard to a one-year, $13 million contract.
The Dodgers essentially traded valuable continuity this offseason for ... almost nothing. Maybe $1-2 million when all is said and done? Not having to worry about one or two contract commitments beyond 2023?
Justin Turner's deal with the Boston Red Sox is for two years and just shy of $22 million, and it includes an opt-out after the first season, sources tell ESPN. https://t.co/9kAFqqX6ay
— Jeff Passan (@JeffPassan) December 18, 2022
The Dodgers letting Justin Turner go to the Red Sox is a bizarre decision
Non-tendering Cody Bellinger to avoid having to pay him ~$19 million and then being unable to retain him because he eventually signed for $17.5 million with the Chicago Cubs anyway was a situation the Dodgers were smart to keep at arms length. That wasn't enough of a financial relief to justify a reunion.
The Justin Turner contract is a one-year deal with a player option for 2024. He’ll get $8.3M in 2023 and $11.4M in 2024. The deal gives the Sox a RHH with pull power (well suited to Fenway) and a disciplined approach. Turner was a force down the stretch in 2022.
— Alex Speier (@alexspeier) December 18, 2022
But the Turner (and Anderson) departures just appear to be a result of apathy? Poor communication? A definitive desire to usher in a changing of the guard? Because why isn't Turner back on a similar deal with the understanding he'd mostly be logging reps at DH and serving as a veteran voice for the up-and-coming young players?
Terms on Justin Turner with Red Sox, per source: Two years, $21.7M if he exercises player option for 2024, one year, $15M if he does not. Can also earn $200K each in ‘23 for 480, 500, 520, 540 and 560 plate appearances. Maximum $1M. Pending physical.
— Ken Rosenthal (@Ken_Rosenthal) December 19, 2022
Was the difference really Turner wanting more money in 2023 or a player option for 2024? And even if one of those two things were important to him, the Dodgers couldn't have given him a buyout for next year that would've reflected that? It's hard to believe that might've been the holdup here since Turner is quite literally a franchise legend.
Whether it was intention or a mistake, the Dodgers are moving on with an eye for the future, and they'll have to make do without some of the organizations most prominent voices of (now) yesteryear.